Imported post
Option three. Can't remember the last time I donned a snorkel - err.....yes I can, Novemeber, 2001, Tiran Straits, Jackson Reef, Dolphins. In with my dive kit (blue water), but never worn, except, as Mark said above, when there are dolphins or Pilot Whales with which to swim.
The above said, I do understand the sense and see the sanity and 'good practise' of newbies and novices learning with one: and Stevie Walker's point about coming in handy for long surface swims or in rough/choppy surface conditions.
With above in mind, it's then up to the individual to either retain or ditch the snorkel as they see fit/comfortable.